Which design should I choose?

I'm currently working on some more oc redesigns and I had 2 different ideas for her jacket thing but sadly can't decide which one to keep.

She is gonna part of my big story world which involves a lot of traveling. Theon, Seth, Athanasios, Kyo and Jenny are also part of the world so I'm trying to make them all look like they could belong to the same area since most of them are traveling as well